Why Google Treats Mismatches as a Trust Signal
Google cannot call you to confirm your business exists at a particular address, so it cross-references what it finds across the web, your website, your Google Business Profile, and third-party citations. When those sources agree, Google gains confidence the business is real, active, and located where it says it is. When they disagree, Google cannot tell which address or number is current, so it hedges by trusting your profile a little less. In practice that shows up as inconsistent Map Pack visibility or, in more severe cases, contributes to a duplicate listing. NAP consistency is not a ranking factor on its own so much as a foundation, it removes doubt so the rest of your local SEO work, reviews, categories, and links, can actually count.